If your child has started lying — even about trivial things — it can trigger worry. Fear creeps in. Many parents assume it signals flawed character, but developmental psychologist Dr. Victoria Talwar sees it differently: lying is a normal developmental milestone. What matters most is how parents respond.
When children lie, it’s rarely about manipulation — it’s about avoiding punishment, protecting themselves, or experimenting with imagination. Your goal isn’t shaming them. It’s helping them see honesty as something safe, rewarding, natural.
This article reveals:
- Why focusing on the reason behind the lie matters more than the act itself.
- How to explain why lying damages trust — in words your child genuinely understands.
- The hidden power of storytelling when teaching honesty.
- Five powerful techniques to try at home.
Key takeaway:
Children become honest not because we tell them lying is bad. They become honest when we demonstrate to them that truthfulness is safe, respected, and deeply valued within our relationship.
Understand why kids lie before you explain
Let’s start with the truth behind the lies.
According to Talwar’s research, children lie for the same core reasons adults do — to avoid negative consequences, chase approval, or protect feelings. For example, a child might lie about breaking something because punishment terrifies them. Or claim they’ve finished homework just to grab more screen time.
Addressing the lie demands understanding your child’s developmental stage.
- If a toddler stands near a wall covered in crayon drawings, asking “Did you do this?” is pointless. Try this instead: “We don’t draw on walls. Let’s clean it together.”
- For older children, you can address lying directly: “In our family, we tell the truth — even when it’s hard.”
Sometimes you need to uncover the reason first. If your child lies for attention, connection beats correction. More play. Shared time. Positive recognition. These often make honesty flow more naturally.
Still, experts emphasize something crucial: even when lies demand immediate response, the more powerful work unfolds in daily life. “Look, the cashier gave that man too much change, but he gave it back. That was honest of him.” Moments like this teach children that truth-telling is a value, not just a rule.
Another perspective: The strongest argument against the gentle approach
Some parenting experts, and grandparents, argue that a gentle, explanatory approach to lying may make children take dishonesty less seriously. They believe kids need clear, firm consequences.Otherwise, kids might interpret empathy as permission
In certain cases, they’re right.
When older children or teens repeatedly and intentionally lie, especially about serious matters like safety, schoolwork, or relationships, a purely gentle approach can fail to establish strong enough boundaries. In these situations, a firm parental response becomes essential to rebuild trust. Boundaries matter. Rules matter. A line must be drawn.
But here’s what research (and experience) keeps proving: fear-based or punitive strategies erode honesty over time. In one of Talwar’s studies, children threatened with punishment were twice as likely to continue lying compared to those gently encouraged toward truth. The fear of punishment might stop a lie today — but it also teaches children that truth-telling is risky.
A balanced approach works best:
- Set firm boundaries — make it crystal clear that lying isn’t acceptable.
- Maintain trust — respond calmly so your child feels safe being honest next time.
So while the “strict consequence” argument carries weight in rare, repeated cases, for most families, empathy paired with consistency fosters lasting honesty far better than fear ever could
Expert-backed techniques to teach honesty
Now, here’s the part most parents don’t usually hear about — the behind-the-scenes tools that help children develop honesty.
Technique #1: The “Truth Warm-Up”
Before asking a child about a possible lie, start with 2–3 “safe truth” questions.
For example: “Did you play with your blue truck today?” or “Did we have spaghetti for lunch?” This lowers their emotional guard. It reminds their brain that truth-telling feels easy and safe. Only then ask about the sensitive topic.
Technique #2: The “Do-Over” formula
When a child lies, instead of saying “You lied,” try this: “That didn’t sound like the full story. Let’s rewind and try again.”
This technique removes shame. Gives the child a second chance to repair trust immediately. Child therapists use it to shift focus from punishment to practice. Kids learn that honesty isn’t about perfection — it’s about being brave enough to try again.
Technique #3: The “Trust Jar”
Get a clear jar and fill it with marbles or beads. Each truthful moment (especially when it’s hard) earns a marble. When the jar fills? Do something together — bake cookies, play a game, take a walk. It’s not bribery. It’s visual trust-building.
Kids see honesty as something that grows over time, just like the jar fills up.
Technique #4: The “Naming the Feeling” shortcut
Experienced psychologists know that most lies are emotional, not logical. When a child lies, calmly reflect what they might be feeling: “I think you were scared I’d be upset.” “It sounds like you didn’t want to disappoint me.”
When children feel seen instead of judged, they relax — and truth follows. Dr. Talwar’s research confirms that empathy before correction leads to more honest responses in future situations.
Technique #5: The “Truth Circle” routine
This is a family ritual some psychologists recommend: once a week, everyone shares one truth from the week — even small ones like “I broke a cup” or “I forgot my homework.” Parents go first to model vulnerability.
The goal isn’t confession — it’s normalizing honesty. It sends a clear message: in this family, truth is safe and shared.
How to help children see why lying is wrong: through the magic of stories
Talwar’s studies show that stories are one of the most powerful ways to teach honesty — far more effective than simply declaring “lying is wrong.” Stories help children visualize honesty, understand emotions, and imagine consequences safely.
Three types of books/stories about lying parents should use:
- Stories showing positive outcomes of honesty — particularly when being truthful requires bravery.
George Washington and the Cherry Tree shows that honesty brings praise, not punishment. Such stories build intrinsic motivation to tell the truth. - Stories where a character needs to decide between telling a lie or true. These books invite reflection and discussion. Ask your child:
“What do you think the character should have done?”
“How do you think they felt when they told the truth?”
“What would you do?”
These reflective questions help children think more deeply about moral choices. - Stories that show the cost or consequences of dishonesty
Books like A Big Fat Enormous Lie or our book Oliver Lies illustrate that dishonesty always carries consequences. It erodes trust and relationships.
When reading, pause to ask questions. Encourage empathy. Connect the story to real life. Storytime becomes a conversation about values, not a lecture.
In one of Talwar’s best-known experiments, children who heard George Washington and the Cherry Tree were twice as likely to tell the truth as those who heard Pinocchio or The Boy Who Cried Wolf.
One last thought
Teaching honesty isn’t a weekend project. It’s a long, looping path filled with tiny conversations and (slow) progress. Children don’t become honest overnight. They absorb it from the rhythm of your words, the tone of your reactions, and the honesty you live by every day.
Respond calmly. Stay curious. Praise truth even when it trembles out awkwardly. Use stories that lift honesty up instead of punishing dishonesty down. Over time, your child won’t just know that honesty matters — they’ll feel why it does. Because honesty grows from trust, not tension.
FAQ
What should parents do if a child continues to lie frequently despite using these techniques?
If lying keeps happening even after trying empathy, stories, and connection, it’s time to look beneath the surface. Persistent lying can signal unmet emotional needs, anxiety, or learned fear.
Here’s what psychologists recommend:
- Pause and observe patterns: When does your child tend to lie — during homework? Around peers? About mistakes? Repeated themes point to triggers such as perfectionism or fear of punishment.
- Check the environment: If your home or school setting feels high-pressure or critical, kids may lie to protect themselves. Reducing fear often reduces lying.
- Reinforce small honesty moments: Even if the truth is partial, say, “Thank you for telling me that part — it helps us solve it together.” This keeps communication open.
- Seek professional guidance: When lying feels compulsive or linked to anxiety, a child psychologist can teach interventions like cognitive reframing (helping kids see the long-term benefits of truth) or behavioral contracts (agreements that pair honesty with predictable outcomes).
The key isn’t to “catch” the child but to understand what the lie protects — fear, pride, or insecurity — and address that.
Disclosure: Some links on Esme Keffe may be affiliate links, meaning we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products and resources we genuinely trust and find valuable for parents and families.
